I got a new laptop! It’s a Framework 13 AMD: 8 cores, 2 threads per core, 64 GB RAM, 3:2 2256×1504 matte screen. It kicks my 5-year-old Dell XPS 13 in the pants, and I am so relieved to be back to a matte screen. I just got it up and running with Guix, which though easier than past installation experiences was not without some wrinkles, so here I wanted to share a recipe for what worked for me.
(I swear this isn’t going to become a product review blog, but when I went to post something like this on the Framework forum I got an error saying that new users could only post 2 links. I understand how we got here but hoo, that is a garbage experience!)
The basic deal
Upstream Guix works on the Framework 13 AMD, but only with software rendering and no wifi, and I wasn’t able to install from upstream media. This is mainly because Guix uses a modified kernel and doesn’t include necessary firmware. There is a third-party nonguix repository that defines packages for the vanilla Linux kernel and the linux-firmware collection; we have to use that repo if we want all functionality.
Of course having the firmware be user-hackable would be better, and it would be better if the framework laptop used parts with free firmware. Something for a next revision, hopefully.
On firmware
As an aside, I think the official Free Software Foundation position on firmware is bad praxis. To recall, the idea is that if a device has embedded software (firmware) that can be updated, but that software is in a form that users can’t modify, then the system as a whole is not free software. This is technically correct but doesn’t logically imply that that the right strategy for advancing free software is to forbid firmware blobs; you have a number of potential policy choices and you have to look at their expected results to evaluate which one is most in line with your goals.
Bright lines are useful, of course; I just think that with respect to free software, drawing that line around firmware is not interesting. To illustrate this point, I believe the current FSF position is that if you can run e.g. a USB ethernet adapter without installing non-free firmware, then it is kosher, otherwise it is haram. However many of these devices have firmware; it’s just that you aren’t updating it. So for example the the USB Ethernet adapter I got with my Dell system many years ago has firmware, therefore it has bugs, but I have never updated that firmware because that’s not how we roll. Or, on my old laptop, I never updated the CPU microcode, despite spectre and meltdown and all the rest.
“Firmware, but never updated” reminds me of the wires around some New York neighborhoods that allow orthodox people to leave the house on Sabbath; useful if you are of a given community and enjoy the feeling of belonging, but I think even the faithful would see it as a hack. It is like how Richard Stallman wouldn’t use travel booking web sites because they had non-free JavaScript, but would happily call someone on the telephone to perform the booking for him, using those same sites. In that case, the net effect on the world of this particular bright line is negative: it does not advance free software in the least and only adds overhead. Privileging principle over praxis is generally a losing strategy.
Installation
Firstly I had to turn off secure boot in the bios settings; it’s in “security”.
I wasn’t expecting wifi to work out of the box, but for some reason the upstream Guix install media was not able to configure the network via the Ethernet expansion card nor an external USB-C ethernet adapter that I had; stuck at the DHCP phase. So my initial installation attempt failed.
Then I realized that the nonguix repository has installation media, which is the same as upstream but with the vanilla kernel and linux-firmware. So on another machine where I had Guix installed, I added the nonguix channel and built the installation media, via guix system image -t iso9660 nongnu/system/install.scm. That gave me a file that I could write to a USB stick.
Using that installation media, installing was a breeze.
However upon reboot, I found that I had no wifi and I was using software rendering; clearly, installation produced an OS config with the Guix kernel instead of upstream Linux. Happily, at this point the ethernet expansion card was able to work, so connect to wired ethernet, open /etc/config.scm, add the needed lines as described in the operating-system part of the nonguix README, reconfigure, and reboot. Building Linux takes a little less than an hour on this machine.
Fractional scaling
At that point you have wifi and graphics drivers. I use GNOME, and things seem to work. However the screen defaults to 200% resolution, which makes everything really big. Crisp, pretty, but big. Really you would like something in between? Or that the Framework ships a higher-resolution screen so that 200% would be a good scaling factor; this was the case with my old Dell XPS 13, and it worked well. Anyway with the Framework laptop, I wanted 150% scaling, and it seems these days that the way you have to do this is to use Wayland, which Guix does not yet enable by default.
So you go into config.scm again, and change where it says %desktop-services to be:
(modify-services %desktop-services
(gdm-service-type config =>
(gdm-configuration (inherit config) (wayland? #t))))
Then when you reboot you are in Wayland. Works fine, it seems. But then you have to go and enable an experimental mutter setting; install dconf-editor, run it, search for keys with “mutter” in the name, find the “experimental settings” key, tell it to not use the default setting, then click the box for “scale-monitor-framebuffer”.
Then! You can go into GNOME settings and get 125%, 150%, and so on. Great.
HOWEVER, and I hope this is a transient situation, there is a problem: in GNOME, applications that aren’t native Wayland apps don’t scale nicely. It’s like the app gets rendered to a texture at the original resolution, which then gets scaled up in a blurry way. There aren’t so many of these apps these days as most things have been ported to be Wayland-capable, Firefox included, but Emacs is one of them 🙁 However however! If you install the emacs-pgtk package instead of emacs, it looks better. Not perfect, but good enough. So that’s where I am.
Bugs
The laptop hangs on reboot due to this bug, but that seems a minor issue at this point. There is an ongoing tracker discussion on the community forum; like other problems in that thread, I hope that this one resolves itself upstream in Linux over time.
Other things?
I didn’t mention the funniest thing about this laptop: it comes in pieces that you have to put together 🙂 I am not so great with hardware, but I had no problem. The build quality seems pretty good; not a MacBook Air, but then it’s also user-repairable, which is a big strong point. It has these funny extension cards that slot into the chassis, which I have found to be quite amusing.
I haven’t had the machine for long enough but it seems to work fine up to now: suspend, good battery use, not noisy (unless it’s compiling on all 16 threads), graphics, wifi, ethernet, good compilation speed. (I should give compiling LLVM a go; that’s a useful workload.) I don’t have bluetooth or the fingerprint reader working yet; I give it 25% odds that I get around to this during the lifetime of this laptop 🙂
Until next time, happy hacking!
